Shared on10 Oct 25Fair value Decreased 25%
CarMax's fair value estimate has been revised sharply lower, dropping from $76.93 to $57.79. Analysts point to mounting sales uncertainty, downward earnings revisions, and lack of visible turnaround strategies following weaker-than-expected Q2 results and multiple price target cuts across the Street.
Shared on26 Sep 25Fair value Decreased 5.53%
CarMax’s consensus price target has been reduced from $81.44 to $76.93 as weaker-than-expected Q2 results, increased uncertainty around future strategy, and ongoing operating headwinds overshadow cautious optimism regarding operational improvements and growth initiatives. Analyst Commentary Weak Q2 results, including a broad earnings miss and underperformance across key metrics, have raised doubts about CarMax's ability to sustain market leadership and deliver additional growth.
Shared on30 Apr 25
AnalystConsensusTarget made no meaningful changes to valuation assumptions.
Shared on23 Apr 25Fair value Decreased 0.68%
AnalystConsensusTarget made no meaningful changes to valuation assumptions.
Shared on16 Apr 25Fair value Decreased 8.39%
AnalystConsensusTarget has decreased revenue growth from 3.6% to 3.0%, decreased profit margin from 3.4% to 2.6% and increased future PE multiple from 16.8x to 20.6x.
Shared on09 Apr 25Fair value Decreased 0.66%
AnalystConsensusTarget made no meaningful changes to valuation assumptions.
Shared on02 Apr 25Fair value Decreased 0.21%
AnalystConsensusTarget made no meaningful changes to valuation assumptions.
Shared on26 Mar 25
AnalystConsensusTarget made no meaningful changes to valuation assumptions.
Shared on19 Mar 25Fair value Decreased 0.14%
AnalystConsensusTarget made no meaningful changes to valuation assumptions.
Shared on10 Mar 25Fair value Increased 8.51%
AnalystConsensusTarget has increased revenue growth from 2.7% to 3.4%, increased profit margin from 2.6% to 3.4% and decreased future PE multiple from 20.8x to 17.0x.