Pantoro Management

Management criteria checks 2/4

Pantoro's CEO is Paul Cmrlec, appointed in Apr 2011, has a tenure of 13.83 years. total yearly compensation is A$890.98K, comprised of 53.9% salary and 46.1% bonuses, including company stock and options. directly owns 0.17% of the company’s shares, worth A$769.74K. The average tenure of the management team and the board of directors is 9.5 years and 2.3 years respectively.

Key information

Paul Cmrlec

Chief executive officer

AU$891.0k

Total compensation

CEO salary percentage	53.9%
CEO tenure	13yrs
CEO ownership	0.2%
Management average tenure	9.5yrs
Board average tenure	2.3yrs

Recent management updates

Recent updates

Pantoro (ASX:PNR) Is Looking To Continue Growing Its Returns On Capital

Jan 13

Pantoro (ASX:PNR) Is Looking To Continue Growing Its Returns On Capital

Sep 06

There's Been No Shortage Of Growth Recently For Pantoro's (ASX:PNR) Returns On Capital

Apr 12

Pantoro's (ASX:PNR) Solid Profits Have Weak Fundamentals

Mar 17

Pantoro Limited's (ASX:PNR) Financials Are Too Obscure To Link With Current Share Price Momentum: What's In Store For the Stock?

Mar 10

What Type Of Shareholders Own The Most Number of Pantoro Limited (ASX:PNR) Shares?

Feb 01

Is Pantoro's (ASX:PNR) Share Price Gain Of 284% Well Earned?

Dec 09

CEO Compensation Analysis

How has Paul Cmrlec's remuneration changed compared to Pantoro's earnings?
Date	Total Compensation	Salary	Company Earnings
Dec 31 2023	n/a	n/a	-AU$45m
Sep 30 2023	n/a	n/a	-AU$60m
Jun 30 2023	AU$891k	AU$480k	-AU$75m
Mar 31 2023	n/a	n/a	-AU$65m
Dec 31 2022	n/a	n/a	-AU$56m
Sep 30 2022	n/a	n/a	-AU$33m
Jun 30 2022	AU$863k	AU$468k	-AU$11m
Mar 31 2022	n/a	n/a	-AU$3m
Dec 31 2021	n/a	n/a	AU$4m
Sep 30 2021	n/a	n/a	AU$8m
Jun 30 2021	AU$749k	AU$480k	AU$12m
Mar 31 2021	n/a	n/a	AU$9m
Dec 31 2020	n/a	n/a	AU$5m
Sep 30 2020	n/a	n/a	-AU$12m
Jun 30 2020	AU$731k	AU$480k	-AU$29m
Mar 31 2020	n/a	n/a	-AU$27m
Dec 31 2019	n/a	n/a	-AU$25m
Sep 30 2019	n/a	n/a	-AU$12m
Jun 30 2019	AU$471k	AU$130k	AU$833k
Mar 31 2019	n/a	n/a	AU$3m
Dec 31 2018	n/a	n/a	AU$5m
Sep 30 2018	n/a	n/a	AU$9m
Jun 30 2018	AU$752k	n/a	AU$14m
Mar 31 2018	n/a	n/a	AU$13m
Dec 31 2017	n/a	n/a	AU$12m
Sep 30 2017	n/a	n/a	-AU$2m
Jun 30 2017	AU$720k	n/a	-AU$16m

Compensation vs Market: Paul's total compensation ($USD579.05K) is about average for companies of similar size in the Australian market ($USD628.85K).

Compensation vs Earnings: Paul's compensation has increased whilst the company is unprofitable.

CEO

Paul Cmrlec

13yrs

Tenure

AU$890,981

Compensation

Mr. Paul Mathew Cmrlec, BEng (Mining), Honours, MAusIMM, served as Non-Executive Director at Maximus Resources Limited since October 18, 2021 until January 27, 2023. He has been Managing Director of Pantor...

Leadership Team

Name	Position	Tenure	Compensation	Ownership
Paul Cmrlec	CEO, MD & Executive Director	13yrs	AU$890.98k	0.17% A$ 769.7k
Scott Balloch	Chief Financial Officer	9.5yrs	AU$470.19k	0.023% A$ 101.2k
Scott Huffadine	Chief Operating Officer	8.1yrs	AU$667.21k	0.061% A$ 271.4k
David Okeby	Company Secretary	9.5yrs	AU$415.66k	0.033% A$ 149.9k
Andrew Finch	Group Geology Manager	4.5yrs	no data	no data

9.5yrs

Average Tenure

Experienced Management: PNR's management team is seasoned and experienced (9.5 years average tenure).

Board Members

Name	Position	Tenure	Compensation	Ownership
Paul Cmrlec	CEO, MD & Executive Director	13.8yrs	AU$890.98k	0.17% A$ 769.7k
Colin McIntyre	Independent Non-Executive Director	less than a year	no data	0.019% A$ 86.0k
Fiona Van Maanen	Independent Non-Executive Director	3.7yrs	AU$99.21k	0.0046% A$ 20.5k
Kevin Maloney	Non-Executive Director	less than a year	no data	0.31% A$ 1.4m
Mark Maloney	Non-Executive Director	less than a year	no data	0.14% A$ 636.7k
Wayne Zekulich	Independent Non-Executive Chairman	4.5yrs	AU$143.48k	0.012% A$ 55.9k

2.3yrs

Average Tenure

60yo

Average Age

Experienced Board: PNR's board of directors are not considered experienced ( 2.3 years average tenure), which suggests a new board.

Pantoro Management

Management criteria checks 2/4

Key information

Recent management updates

Independent Non-Executive Director recently sold AU$350k worth of stock

Independent Non-Executive Director recently sold AU$155k worth of stock

Pantoro Limited, Annual General Meeting, Nov 06, 2023

Less than half of directors are independent

Pantoro Limited, Annual General Meeting, Nov 28, 2022

CEO, MD & Executive Director exercised options to buy AU$55k worth of stock.

Recent updates

First half 2024 earnings released: AU$0.003 loss per share (vs AU$0.028 loss in 1H 2023)

Independent Non-Executive Director recently sold AU$350k worth of stock

Price target decreased by 8.0% to AU$0.051

New major risk - Financial position

Consensus estimates of losses per share improve by 11%

Independent Non-Executive Director recently sold AU$155k worth of stock

Consensus estimates of losses per share improve by 28%

New major risk - Financial position

New minor risk - Market cap size

New minor risk - Share price stability

Full year 2023 earnings released: AU$0.037 loss per share (vs AU$0.007 loss in FY 2022)

New minor risk - Financial data availability

Pantoro Limited, Annual General Meeting, Nov 06, 2023

Price target decreased by 57% to AU$0.10

Pantoro Limited has completed a Follow-on Equity Offering in the amount of AUD 30 million.

Pantoro Limited has completed a Follow-on Equity Offering in the amount of AUD 30 million.

Price target decreased by 36% to AU$0.23

Less than half of directors are independent

First half 2023 earnings released: AU$0.028 loss per share (vs AU$0 in 1H 2022)

Pantoro Limited (ASX:PNR) entered into a implementation deed to acquire Tulla Resources Plc (ASX:TUL) from Tulla Resources Group Pty Limited and others for approximately AUD 140 million.

Beacon Minerals Limited (ASX:BCN) acquired 19.82% stake in Maximus Resources Limited (ASX:MXR) from Pantoro Limited (ASX:PNR) for AUD0.042 per share.

Beacon Minerals Limited (ASX:BCN) agreed to acquire 19.82% stake in Maximus Resources Limited (ASX:MXR) from Pantoro Limited (ASX:PNR) for AUD0.042 per share.

Pantoro Limited has completed a Follow-on Equity Offering in the amount of AUD 28.5 million.

Pantoro Announces Lamboo PGE Drilling Identifies New High Grade Reef System with Nickel and Copper Sulphides

Pantoro Limited Provides Results as It Advances the Phase Two Exploration Drilling Program Targeting the High Grade Mainfield At the Norseman Gold Project

Pantoro Limited Announces First Gold Poured At the Norseman Gold Project

Pantoro Limited, Annual General Meeting, Nov 28, 2022

Full year 2022 earnings: EPS and revenues miss analyst expectations

Pantoro Limited Reports Initial Results from Norseman Lithium JV

An unknown buyer acquired an unknown minority stake in Pantoro Limited (ASX:PNR) from Tulla Resources Group Pty Limited.

Pantoro Limited Provides an Update of Project Construction and Mining Activities At the Norseman Project

Pantoro Limited Provides an Update of Project Construction and Mining Activities At the Norseman Project

Pantoro Limited Announces an Update to the Mineral Resource and Ore Reserve At the Green Lantern Deposit, Part of the Scotia Mining Centre At the Norseman Project

Pantoro Limited Announces Update to the Mineral Resource and Ore Reserve At the Green Lantern Deposit, Part of the Scotia Mining Centre At the Norseman Project

Pantoro Limited Announces Drilling Results from Green Lantern at the Norseman Project

Pantoro Limited to Advise That the Initial 2022 Step Out Drilling at the Lamboo

CEO, MD & Executive Director exercised options to buy AU$55k worth of stock.

Independent Non-Executive Director recently bought AU$84k worth of stock

Pantoro Limited Provides an Update of Project Construction and Mining Activities At the Norseman Project

Pantoro Limited Provides an Update on the PGE Potential on Its Tenure in the Norseman Region

Pantoro Limited Announces 20,000 M Drill Programme Commences at Lamboo PGE Project

Consensus forecasts updated

Pantoro Limited Announces an Update to the Mineral Resource Estimates and Ore Reserve At the Scotia Deposit

First half 2022 earnings: EPS exceeds analyst expectations

Pantoro Limited Announces the Results from the Drilling Completed Late Last Year Prior to the Wet Season

Pantoro Limited Announces Operations Update At Both Its Norseman and Halls Creek Projects

Consensus EPS estimates fall by 17%

Pantoro (ASX:PNR) Is Looking To Continue Growing Its Returns On Capital

Pantoro Limited Announces Significant Lamboo PGE Strike Extension

Pantoro Limited Announces Lamboo PGE Drilling to Continue

Full year 2021 earnings released: EPS AU$0.009 (vs AU$0.025 loss in FY 2020)

Pantoro Limited Provide Its Annual Mineral Resource and Ore Reserve Statement

Price target increased to AU$0.27

Pantoro Limited Announces Maiden Mineral Resource Estimate and Ore Reserve at the Green Lantern Deposit, Part of the Scotia Mining Centre at the Norseman Gold Project

Pantoro (ASX:PNR) Is Looking To Continue Growing Its Returns On Capital

Price target decreased to AU$0.25

Pantoro Limited Provides Results from its Initial Drilling Program Targeting the Historic Mainfield at the Norseman Gold Project

Pantoro Limited Announces Third New Discovery At the Scotia Mining Centre

Pantoro Limited Announces Further High-Grade Results from A Ten Hole Infill Drilling Program on the Sailfish Prospect on Lake Cowan At the Norseman Gold Project

Pantoro Limited Identifies High Grade Mineralisation at the Lord Percy Deposit

Pantoro Limited Announces Deep Drilling At Scotia Confirms High Grade Mineralisation

Consensus EPS estimates fall to AU$0.01

There's Been No Shortage Of Growth Recently For Pantoro's (ASX:PNR) Returns On Capital

Pantoro's (ASX:PNR) Solid Profits Have Weak Fundamentals

First half 2021 earnings released: EPS AU$0.006 (vs AU$0.022 loss in 1H 2020)

Pantoro Limited's (ASX:PNR) Financials Are Too Obscure To Link With Current Share Price Momentum: What's In Store For the Stock?

GR Engineering Services Limited Receives Letter of Intent from Pantoro Limited for the Engineering, Procurement and Construction of a New Processing Plant for its Norseman Gold Project

What Type Of Shareholders Own The Most Number of Pantoro Limited (ASX:PNR) Shares?

Pantoro Limited Provides Update on its Regional Exploration Activities at its 100% Owned Halls Creek Project, Located in the East Kimberley Region in Western Australia