U.S. Insurance Dividend Stocks

UPDATED Jun 22, 2025

Discover U.S. Insurance High Yield Dividend Stocks that are on the NYSE and NASDAQ and sorted by Dividend Yield. An upper limit of 20% is in place to filter out stocks with potentially unsustainable dividends. All companies with high dividend yields (above 5%) should be researched for sustainability. For more options please click on 'Advanced Filters'.

71 companies
CompanyLast Price7D Return1Y ReturnMarket CapAnalysts TargetValuationGrowthDiv Yield
AMSF
AMERISAFE
US$43.50-2.1%2.1%US$828.2mUS$56.33PE17.4xE-7.6%10.5%
CNA
CNA Financial
US$45.29-0.4%0.6%US$12.3bUS$45.00PE13.7xE19.4%8.5%
ITIC
Investors Title
US$203.030.1%13.9%US$383.0mn/aPE12.9xn/a7.8%
ACGL
Arch Capital Group
US$90.17-1.1%-12.0%US$33.7bUS$111.79PE9xE3.8%5.5%
LNC
Lincoln National
US$33.01-0.3%2.3%US$5.6bUS$38.09PE4.5xE7.5%5.5%
PRU
Prudential Financial
US$104.33-0.6%-12.4%US$36.9bUS$113.29PE16.3xE14.2%5.2%
SAFT
Safety Insurance Group
US$77.88-1.5%1.9%US$1.2bn/aPE16.1xn/a4.6%
GBLI
Global Indemnity Group
US$32.51-1.5%5.7%US$464.1mUS$55.00PE16.9xE28.2%4.3%
PFG
Principal Financial Group
US$76.61-0.2%-5.2%US$17.2bUS$82.50PE15.8xE19.2%4.0%
DGIC.A
Donegal Group
US$19.07-0.4%52.0%US$690.2mUS$19.50PE9.8xE3.0%3.8%
FNF
Fidelity National Financial
US$54.51-0.6%9.5%US$15.0bUS$70.75PE13.5xE19.9%3.7%
FAF
First American Financial
US$58.870.2%8.0%US$6.1bUS$77.00PE38.2xE39.7%3.7%
RLI
RLI
US$72.18-1.2%2.2%US$6.6bUS$77.25PE23.6xE5.0%3.6%
HMN
Horace Mann Educators
US$42.14-0.02%26.9%US$1.7bUS$46.50PE15xE18.4%3.3%
STC
Stewart Information Services
US$62.780.08%2.1%US$1.8bUS$75.00PE23.9xE31.3%3.2%
ORI
Old Republic International
US$37.310.08%19.9%US$9.1bUS$42.00PE11.6xE2.6%3.1%
UVE
Universal Insurance Holdings
US$26.39-1.2%42.5%US$742.7mUS$29.00PE11.1xE12.6%2.9%
WDH
Waterdrop
US$1.396.1%18.8%US$502.7mUS$1.85PE9.1xE15.0%2.9%
MET
MetLife
US$79.211.0%9.8%US$53.2bUS$92.71PE12.4xE7.3%2.9%
FG
F&G Annuities & Life
US$31.630.3%-17.7%US$4.3bUS$37.00PE8.8xS10.2%2.8%
EIG
Employers Holdings
US$46.54-0.7%9.9%US$1.1bUS$55.50PE10.9xE-12.1%2.8%
CRD.B
Crawford
US$10.2410.2%19.3%US$513.1mUS$14.00PE16.6xE19.4%2.7%
AFG
American Financial Group
US$123.82-0.1%-2.1%US$10.3bUS$132.20PE12.9xE8.7%2.6%
FIHL
Fidelis Insurance Holdings
US$15.93-1.8%-1.4%US$1.8bUS$19.39PB0.7xE62.6%2.5%
Page 1 of 3