U.S. Insurance Dividend Stocks

UPDATED Jul 18, 2024

Discover U.S. Insurance High Yield Dividend Stocks that are on the NYSE and NASDAQ and sorted by Dividend Yield. An upper limit of 20% is in place to filter out stocks with potentially unsustainable dividends. All companies with high dividend yields (above 5%) should be researched for sustainability. For more options please click on ‘Advanced Filters’.

71 companies
CompanyLast Price7D Return1Y ReturnMarket CapAnalysts TargetValuationGrowthDiv Yield

AMSF

AMERISAFE
US$48.528.4%-10.5%US$931.4mUS$56.00PE15xE-22.9%10.3%

CNA

CNA Financial
US$48.864.2%25.4%US$13.2bUS$45.00PE10.6xE6.1%7.7%

LNC

Lincoln National
US$32.190.8%17.5%US$5.6bUS$32.10PE4.3xE2.0%5.6%

DGIC.A

Donegal Group
US$14.155.9%-3.5%US$475.6mUS$13.75PE91.3xE63.6%4.9%

GBLI

Global Indemnity Group
US$30.541.1%-5.2%US$415.5mUS$55.00PE12.3xE3.4%4.6%

PRU

Prudential Financial
US$125.302.4%31.9%US$45.7bUS$117.08PE21xE14.7%4.2%

SAFT

Safety Insurance Group
US$86.7511.6%25.2%US$1.3bn/aPE25.2xn/a4.1%

UVE

Universal Insurance Holdings
US$19.766.6%25.3%US$570.0mUS$25.00PE7.4xE1.5%3.9%

HMN

Horace Mann Educators
US$34.964.7%17.9%US$1.4bUS$38.50PE22.1xE44.0%3.9%

FAF

First American Financial
US$57.632.9%-2.4%US$6.1bUS$65.00PE27.5xE32.8%3.7%

FNF

Fidelity National Financial
US$53.313.9%40.2%US$14.9bUS$58.33PE17.7xE22.3%3.6%

PFG

Principal Financial Group
US$85.341.7%2.2%US$20.5bUS$85.92PE15.4xE12.9%3.3%

ORI

Old Republic International
US$32.263.8%21.5%US$8.6bUS$34.00PE12xE3.1%3.3%

CRD.B

Crawford
US$8.531.1%-2.1%US$454.9mUS$11.00PE18.4xE43.1%3.3%

ITIC

Investors Title
US$199.7610.7%32.7%US$374.0mn/aPE15xn/a2.9%

MET

MetLife
US$75.394.1%23.7%US$54.2bUS$82.41PE24.8xE18.3%2.9%

UFCS

United Fire Group
US$22.436.3%-4.6%US$568.7mUS$21.00PB0.8xS12.6%2.9%

STC

Stewart Information Services
US$69.483.4%53.2%US$2.0bUS$70.00PE45.9xE42.7%2.7%

UNM

Unum Group
US$53.564.0%9.2%US$10.2bUS$59.91PE7.7xE4.9%2.7%

CINF

Cincinnati Financial
US$126.013.8%22.9%US$19.9bUS$133.29PE8.3xE-38.8%2.6%

EIG

Employers Holdings
US$46.718.0%26.8%US$1.2bUS$52.50PE9.6xE-13.5%2.6%

THG

Hanover Insurance Group
US$133.387.1%18.6%US$4.8bUS$150.86PE29.8xE54.0%2.5%

JRVR

James River Group Holdings
US$8.216.5%-55.8%US$318.5mUS$11.40PE4.7xE14.4%2.4%

AXS

AXIS Capital Holdings
US$73.684.7%35.1%US$6.2bUS$78.17PE11.1xE14.6%2.4%
Page 1 of 3
Simply Wall Street Pty Ltd (ACN 600 056 611), is a Corporate Authorised Representative (Authorised Representative Number: 467183) of Sanlam Private Wealth Pty Ltd (AFSL No. 337927). Any advice contained in this website is general advice only and has been prepared without considering your objectives, financial situation or needs. You should not rely on any advice and/or information contained in this website and before making any investment decision we recommend that you consider whether it is appropriate for your situation and seek appropriate financial, taxation and legal advice. Please read our Financial Services Guide before deciding whether to obtain financial services from us.