U.S. Insurance Dividend Stocks

UPDATED Jan 11, 2026

Discover U.S. Insurance High Yield Dividend Stocks that are on the NYSE and NASDAQ and sorted by Dividend Yield. An upper limit of 20% is in place to filter out stocks with potentially unsustainable dividends. All companies with high dividend yields (above 5%) should be researched for sustainability. For more options please click on 'Advanced Filters'.

Discover Top Quality U.S. Dividend Stocks

72 companies

Company	Last Price	7D Return	1Y Return	Market Cap	Analysts Target	Valuation	Growth	Div Yield
CNA	US$46.35	-2.3%	0.2%	US$12.5b	US$47.00	12.6	15.2%	8.3%
AMSF	US$37.44	-2.6%	-25.0%	US$708.1m	US$49.33	14.2	-12.6%	6.8%
ACIC	US$11.31	-1.0%	-5.8%	US$551.5m	US$14.00	6.4	-10.5%	6.6%
PGR	US$215.16	1.1%	-8.7%	US$126.2b	US$251.53	11.8	-5.1%	6.5%
RELI	US$0.53	-5.3%	-70.6%	US$5.3m	n/a	0.8	n/a	5.6%
GBLI	US$28.63	1.5%	-15.8%	US$410.1m	US$55.00	14.9	47.2%	4.9%
SAFT	US$75.81	0.4%	-2.9%	US$1.1b	n/a	13.0	n/a	4.9%
PRU	US$118.08	0.6%	1.5%	US$41.3b	US$118.71	16.0	13.5%	4.6%
IGIC	US$23.44	-6.2%	-0.5%	US$992.1m	US$30.00	8.0	-0.5%	4.5%
RLI	US$60.15	-3.6%	-20.0%	US$5.5b	US$65.00	15.6	-7.9%	4.4%
ITIC	US$252.99	-0.6%	16.3%	US$477.5m	n/a	13.3	n/a	4.2%
LNC	US$43.78	-5.3%	42.3%	US$8.3b	US$46.50	4.1	0.6%	4.1%
FNF	US$54.95	-1.3%	1.1%	US$14.9b	US$70.00	12.8	18.7%	3.8%
DGIC.A	US$19.79	2.1%	38.1%	US$713.5m	US$21.50	8.4	-5.1%	3.7%
FAF	US$61.49	-1.1%	5.6%	US$6.3b	US$76.60	13.0	9.1%	3.6%
PFG	US$90.29	-0.2%	16.1%	US$19.8b	US$91.82	12.6	17.5%	3.5%
FG	US$28.75	-1.6%	-27.2%	US$3.9b	US$32.00	8.7	9.5%	3.5%
WDH	US$1.85	-2.6%	60.9%	US$669.1m	US$2.25	9.2	16.0%	3.2%
KMPR	US$39.76	0%	-37.5%	US$2.3b	US$58.20	9.4	22.7%	3.2%
FIHL	US$19.02	-2.5%	15.8%	US$2.0b	US$21.33	0.8	47.2%	3.2%
HMN	US$44.48	-2.3%	19.7%	US$1.8b	US$50.67	11.0	11.8%	3.1%
STC	US$68.64	-3.8%	15.3%	US$2.1b	US$81.50	20.3	22.1%	3.1%
EIG	US$44.28	1.9%	-7.9%	US$995.4m	US$44.50	15.9	-7.3%	2.9%
MET	US$79.41	-2.9%	-3.1%	US$52.3b	US$91.93	14.4	16.5%	2.9%

Page 1 of 3