Advanced Filters

Page 2 - U.S. Insurance Dividend Stocks

UPDATED Apr 12, 2026

Discover U.S. Insurance High Yield Dividend Stocks that are on the NYSE and NASDAQ and sorted by Dividend Yield. An upper limit of 20% is in place to filter out stocks with potentially unsustainable dividends. All companies with high dividend yields (above 5%) should be researched for sustainability. For more options please click on 'Advanced Filters'.

Discover Top Quality U.S. Dividend Stocks
73 companies
CompanyLast Price7D Return1Y ReturnMarket CapAnalysts TargetValuationGrowthDiv Yield
FIHL
US$20.053.9%24.1%US$1.7bUS$22.397.713.0%3.0%
CRD.B
US$10.17-0.2%-0.5%US$504.9mUS$14.0025.340.2%2.9%
WRB
US$65.70-0.7%-5.2%US$24.6bUS$67.1913.82.6%2.8%
AFG
US$130.690.6%1.7%US$10.9bUS$140.5012.97.6%2.7%
ABX
US$8.121.4%0.4%US$783.9mUS$13.4021.734.4%2.5%
EG
US$329.870.4%-6.6%US$14.8bUS$362.739.413.8%2.4%
UNM
US$76.671.1%-0.3%US$12.6bUS$93.6217.016.2%2.4%
AIG
US$76.870.6%-5.7%US$41.1bUS$87.1513.35.5%2.3%
CINF
US$161.140.7%20.9%US$25.1bUS$173.5010.5-27.4%2.3%
ERIE
US$253.76-0.2%-40.1%US$13.3bn/a23.7n/a2.3%
UVE
US$34.392.0%51.8%US$963.2mUS$40.005.3-22.8%2.2%
AFL
US$110.700.4%2.0%US$57.0bUS$112.1415.61.0%2.2%
SIGI
US$79.942.9%-9.1%US$4.8bUS$87.2910.58.2%2.2%
THG
US$176.780.8%10.9%US$6.2bUS$198.009.4-0.5%2.1%
MRSH
US$168.15-3.8%-29.1%US$81.4bUS$204.4019.67.6%2.1%
ALL
US$210.991.3%7.9%US$54.5bUS$239.435.4-23.6%2.0%
UFCS
US$39.144.1%45.8%US$998.9mUS$40.508.5-9.3%2.0%
PRI
US$261.222.9%1.2%US$8.2bUS$294.0011.03.0%1.8%
RGA
US$205.05-1.7%13.2%US$13.4bUS$248.7811.414.2%1.8%
AXS
US$98.14-3.3%3.8%US$7.3bUS$123.367.44.8%1.8%
HIG
US$137.230.6%16.6%US$37.7bUS$150.209.91.7%1.7%
AGO
US$81.960.4%-0.05%US$3.7bUS$105.757.4-30.5%1.7%
CNO
US$42.251.6%11.6%US$4.0bUS$46.0017.316.2%1.6%
AIZ
US$219.400.6%12.5%US$10.9bUS$260.0012.610.7%1.6%
Page 2 of 4