Page 5 - Small Cap U.S. Insurance Stocks by Market Cap

UPDATED Nov 19, 2025

Discover small cap U.S. Insurance companies that are on the NYSE and NASDAQ. These Insurance Companies are organised by Market Cap.

115 companies
CompanyLast Price7D Return1Y ReturnMarket CapAnalysts TargetValuationGrowthDiv Yield
L
Loews
US$105.301.2%24.6%US$21.7bn/aPE15xn/a0.2%
CINF
Cincinnati Financial
US$161.65-3.1%6.6%US$25.3bUS$171.00PE11.9xE-21.0%2.2%
MKL
Markel Group
US$2,040.75-2.4%20.5%US$25.9bUS$2,013.40PE14.2xE-0.2%n/a
BRO
Brown & Brown
US$78.81-1.7%-28.1%US$27.3bUS$95.00PE27.2xE17.0%0.8%
WRB
W. R. Berkley
US$76.690.05%25.8%US$29.5bUS$74.20PE15.3xE1.3%1.8%
WTW
Willis Towers Watson
US$317.37-0.8%2.8%US$30.6bUS$367.28PE14.4xE-6.0%1.2%
ACGL
Arch Capital Group
US$91.17-0.7%-4.7%US$33.1bUS$107.76PE8.1xE-3.3%n/a
PRU
Prudential Financial
US$103.56-3.9%-16.6%US$35.9bUS$116.57PE14xE14.4%5.2%
HIG
Hartford Insurance Group
US$132.18-0.4%11.8%US$37.1bUS$142.06PE10.4xE2.1%1.8%
AIG
American International Group
US$75.75-2.9%1.5%US$41.6bUS$88.33PE12.4xE5.4%2.4%
MET
MetLife
US$74.76-6.8%-9.5%US$49.7bUS$92.47PE13.6xE16.1%3.0%
ALL
Allstate
US$209.930.3%6.4%US$54.9bUS$236.10PE6.6xE-20.5%1.9%
AFL
Aflac
US$109.40-4.5%-0.8%US$58.6bUS$111.38PE13.8xE1.4%2.2%
TRV
Travelers Companies
US$285.47-0.2%11.0%US$64.0bUS$295.60PE10.9xE-2.3%1.5%
AJG
Arthur J. Gallagher
US$248.72-2.8%-15.9%US$66.4bUS$319.80PE39.9xE20.0%1.0%
AON
Aon
US$344.17-1.7%-9.4%US$74.9bUS$402.67PE27.2xE12.0%0.9%
MMC
Marsh & McLennan Companies
US$177.13-3.1%-20.2%US$88.3bUS$214.26PE21xE8.7%2.0%
CB
Chubb
US$293.96-0.3%3.9%US$116.7bUS$307.73PE12xE3.5%1.3%
PGR
Progressive
US$222.930.5%-13.3%US$131.9bUS$256.55PE12.2xE-4.9%2.2%
Page 5 of 5