Page 2 - Small Cap U.S. Insurance Stocks by Market Cap

Name: Financial Insights Based on S&P Global Market Intelligence
Creator: Simply Wall St Pty Ltd
License: https://www.spglobal.com/content/dam/spglobal/corporate/en/documents/secure/MI-FastTrack-Terms-and-Conditions-July-2023.pdf

UPDATED Nov 23, 2025

Discover small cap U.S. Insurance companies that are on the NYSE and NASDAQ. These Insurance Companies are organised by Market Cap.

115 companies

Company	Last Price	7D Return	1Y Return	Market Cap	Analysts Target	Valuation	Growth	Div Yield
OSG Octave Specialty Group	US$8.98	-2.1%	-30.0%	US$393.4m	US$16.33	PS1.5x	E64.7%	n/a
GLRE Greenlight Capital Re	US$13.00	0.9%	-13.8%	US$443.3m	n/a	PB0.7x	n/a	n/a
ITIC Investors Title	US$271.44	-2.2%	-4.1%	US$512.4m	n/a	PE14.2x	n/a	5.8%
CRD.B Crawford	US$10.61	1.0%	-4.4%	US$538.7m	US$14.00	PE16x	E16.0%	2.8%
ABL Abacus Global Management	US$5.81	-6.6%	-24.3%	US$567.9m	US$13.10	PE51.4x	E63.5%	n/a
ACIC American Coastal Insurance	US$11.70	0.3%	-13.8%	US$570.6m	US$14.00	PE6.6x	E-10.5%	0%
WDH Waterdrop	US$1.65	3.8%	51.4%	US$596.7m	US$2.24	PE9.5x	E17.9%	3.6%
DGIC.A Donegal Group	US$19.75	-1.2%	23.6%	US$703.8m	US$21.00	PE8.4x	E-3.3%	3.7%
TIPT Tiptree	US$18.62	-3.1%	-15.3%	US$704.3m	n/a	PE14x	n/a	1.3%
AMSF AMERISAFE	US$40.67	-2.2%	-30.7%	US$769.2m	US$49.33	PE15.4x	E-12.6%	6.3%
HRTG Heritage Insurance Holdings	US$27.10	-13.0%	118.7%	US$791.9m	US$35.50	PE5.3x	E-5.1%	0%
HIPO Hippo Holdings	US$32.27	2.8%	-5.1%	US$817.6m	US$40.33	PE8.5x	E-87.0%	n/a
ASIC Ategrity Specialty Insurance Company Holdings	US$18.14	-5.9%	n/a	US$871.9m	US$25.80	PE12.6x	E28.3%	n/a
EIG Employers Holdings	US$39.44	1.0%	-26.0%	US$886.6m	US$44.50	PE14.2x	E-7.3%	3.2%
BOW Bowhead Specialty Holdings	US$27.46	-0.7%	-23.3%	US$900.2m	US$34.83	PE17.1x	E23.2%	n/a
YB Yuanbao	US$19.94	-4.9%	n/a	US$918.8m	n/a	PE4.2x	n/a	n/a
UVE Universal Insurance Holdings	US$33.36	-2.4%	45.2%	US$935.7m	US$35.00	PE7.6x	E-8.9%	2.3%
UFCS United Fire Group	US$36.92	0.9%	21.2%	US$942.0m	US$36.50	PE8.5x	E-9.2%	1.7%
IGIC International General Insurance Holdings	US$23.58	0.6%	-9.2%	US$998.0m	US$32.00	PE8x	n/a	4.5%
SAFT Safety Insurance Group	US$76.94	1.1%	-10.4%	US$1.1b	n/a	PE13.2x	n/a	4.8%
ROOT Root	US$75.54	-7.7%	-30.8%	US$1.2b	US$126.75	PE21.7x	E7.5%	n/a
PRA ProAssurance	US$24.05	0.2%	44.5%	US$1.2b	US$22.67	PE36.7x	E25.6%	0%
MAAS Maase	US$3.91	-0.6%	n/a	US$1.2b	n/a	n/a	n/a	n/a
TRUP Trupanion	US$35.90	-4.9%	-33.0%	US$1.6b	US$54.75	PE100.3x	E31.6%	n/a

Page 2 of 5