Did ICC Holdings Inc (NASDAQ:ICCH) Create Value For Investors Over The Past Year?

This analysis is intended to introduce important early concepts to people who are starting to invest and want to begin learning the link between company’s fundamentals and stock market performance.

ICC Holdings Inc’s (NASDAQ:ICCH) most recent return on equity was a substandard 0.86% relative to its industry performance of 9.42% over the past year. An investor may attribute an inferior ROE to a relatively inefficient performance, and whilst this can often be the case, knowing the nuts and bolts of the ROE calculation may change that perspective and give you a deeper insight into ICCH’s past performance. I will take you through how metrics such as financial leverage impact ROE which may affect the overall sustainability of ICCH’s returns.

Check out our latest analysis for ICC Holdings

Breaking down ROE — the mother of all ratios

Firstly, Return on Equity, or ROE, is simply the percentage of last years’ earning against the book value of shareholders’ equity. An ROE of 0.86% implies $0.0086 returned on every $1 invested, so the higher the return, the better. Investors that are diversifying their portfolio based on industry may want to maximise their return in the Property and Casualty Insurance sector by choosing the highest returning stock. But this can be misleading as each company has different costs of equity and also varying debt levels, which could artificially push up ROE whilst accumulating high interest expense.

Return on Equity = Net Profit ÷ Shareholders Equity

ROE is measured against cost of equity in order to determine the efficiency of ICC Holdings’s equity capital deployed. Its cost of equity is 8.59%. Given a discrepancy of -7.73% between return and cost, this indicated that ICC Holdings may be paying more for its capital than what it’s generating in return. ROE can be dissected into three distinct ratios: net profit margin, asset turnover, and financial leverage. This is called the Dupont Formula:

Dupont Formula

ROE = profit margin × asset turnover × financial leverage

ROE = (annual net profit ÷ sales) × (sales ÷ assets) × (assets ÷ shareholders’ equity)

ROE = annual net profit ÷ shareholders’ equity

NasdaqCM:ICCH Last Perf July 16th 18
NasdaqCM:ICCH Last Perf July 16th 18

Basically, profit margin measures how much of revenue trickles down into earnings which illustrates how efficient the business is with its cost management. Asset turnover reveals how much revenue can be generated from ICC Holdings’s asset base. The most interesting ratio, and reflective of sustainability of its ROE, is financial leverage. We can assess whether ICC Holdings is fuelling ROE by excessively raising debt. Ideally, ICC Holdings should have a balanced capital structure, which we can check by looking at the historic debt-to-equity ratio of the company. The most recent ratio is 5.60%, which is sensible and indicates ICC Holdings has not taken on too much leverage. Thus, we can conclude its below-average ROE may be a result of low debt, and ICC Holdings still has room to increase leverage and grow future returns.

NasdaqCM:ICCH Historical Debt July 16th 18
NasdaqCM:ICCH Historical Debt July 16th 18

Next Steps:

ROE is one of many ratios which meaningfully dissects financial statements, which illustrates the quality of a company. ICC Holdings exhibits a weak ROE against its peers, as well as insufficient levels to cover its own cost of equity this year. However, ROE is not likely to be inflated by excessive debt funding, giving shareholders more conviction in the sustainability of returns, which has headroom to increase further. ROE is a helpful signal, but it is definitely not sufficient on its own to make an investment decision.

For ICC Holdings, I’ve compiled three relevant aspects you should further research:

  1. Financial Health: Does it have a healthy balance sheet? Take a look at our free balance sheet analysis with six simple checks on key factors like leverage and risk.
  2. Future Earnings: How does ICC Holdings’s growth rate compare to its peers and the wider market? Dig deeper into the analyst consensus number for the upcoming years by interacting with our free analyst growth expectation chart.
  3. Other High-Growth Alternatives : Are there other high-growth stocks you could be holding instead of ICC Holdings? Explore our interactive list of stocks with large growth potential to get an idea of what else is out there you may be missing!