Loading...
Back to narrative

The Narrative Shift Has Arrived. And It Arrived With Vengeance

Update shared on 27 Nov 2025

Fair value Increased 15%
n/a
n/a
BlackGoat's Fair Value
n/a
Loading
1Y
67.2%
7D
0.4%

In July, I wrote that Google was the "cheapest AI play in the market," trading at 18x earnings because Wall Street was obsessed with two phantom risks: the "death of Search" via ChatGPT and a DOJ breakup.

Fast forward 20 weeks. The stock has gone parabolic, ripping from $177 to over $320. The narrative didn't just shift; it completely inverted. Google isn't being priced as a "dying incumbent" anymore, it’s now being priced as the inevitable AI infrastructure king.

Here is why the thesis played out faster than expected, and what we do now.

1. Search Revenue: What Disruption?

The "Search is Dead" bears have gone into hibernation. Search revenue didn't shrink; it accelerated. It turns out that integrating Gemini into Search (AI Overviews) didn't kill the ad model, it increased engagement. The transition was smooth, and Google proved it can monetize AI answers just as effectively as blue links.

2. Execution Alpha: Gemini 3 Ended the Debate

Back in July, the consensus was that OpenAI was "miles ahead." That gap has not only closed; it has reversed.

  • Gemini 3 dropped this month and is sweeping the benchmarks. It is currently beating GPT-5.1 on reasoning and coding tasks.
  • Adoption: We are seeing this show up in the numbers. 650M Monthly Active Users (MAUs) for Gemini is a staggering acceleration.
  • The "Vibe Shift": Salesforce CEO Marc Benioff recently tweeted he’s "not going back" to ChatGPT after using Gemini 3. That is the kind of enterprise validation you can't buy.
  • Advantage Realized: As predicted, Google’s distribution (Android + Workspace) + Clean Data = Winning Product. The "laggard" label is officially retired.

3. The Regulatory "Nothingburger"

The DOJ antitrust case, the single biggest overhang on the stock, effectively dissolved with the changing political winds. With the new administration signalling a lighter touch on tech M&A and breakups, the "Existential Breakup Risk" (divesting Chrome/Android) has gone from a 30% probability to near zero. The market hates uncertainty; removing that tail risk instantly repriced the multiple.

4. Cloud & Infrastructure: The New Crown Jewel

While everyone was watching Search ads, Google Cloud became a monster.

  • Growth: Revenue accelerated to 34% YoY ($15.2B in Q3). This is no longer a distant third; it is the growth engine.
  • Strategic Wins: Securing the NATO sovereign cloud contract is a massive signal of trust. If NATO trusts Google with its secrets, enterprises will trust them with their data.
  • The TPU Coup: This is the most bullish "fresh" rumour in the market: Meta is reportedly in talks to buy/lease Google TPUs instead of relying solely on Nvidia GPUs. If true, this transforms Google from just a "chip user" to a "chip supplier" for the rest of Big Tech. That is a multi-billion dollar revenue stream that wasn't in anyone's model in July.

5. The Ultimate Validation: The Buffett Stamp

The biggest signal wasn't a product launch; it was a SEC filing. Berkshire Hathaway disclosed a $5B stake in Alphabet in Q3. Warren Buffett doesn't buy "speculative tech." He buys wide moats, cash flow, and rational valuation. His entry effectively killed the bear case. It told the market: “The moat is intact, and the price is wrong.” When the Oracle of Omaha validates your value thesis, the floor on the stock price rises overnight.

6. Waymo: The Quiet Expansion

Tesla still owns the "vision-only" narrative, but Waymo owns the roads. They are now live in 5+ major cities (Miami, Austin, etc.). While I still believe Tesla wins the global scale game eventually, Waymo has proven it is a real, revenue-generating business today, not a science project.

The New Setup: Why I am Cautious Short-Term

The fundamentals are flawless. However, as an investor, I must respect price action and psychology.

When I wrote the original thesis, everyone hated the stock. Now, Jim Cramer just told his followers to "Buy" Google. This is never a good thing... When the last bear capitulates and the mainstream media starts chasing a stock after an 80% run, the easy money has been made.

  • Valuation: We are no longer at 18x earnings. We are trading close to my fair value estimates.
  • Technical: An 80% move in 5 months is a "parabolic" advance. Stocks rarely sustain this angle of attack without a cool-off or some sort of consolidation.

Conclusion: Hold the Compounder (...And Trim the Euphoria?)

I believe Alphabet has been correctly repriced. The "Value Gap" I identified in July is closed.

  • Short Term: I expect consolidation. The stock needs to digest these gains, likely chopping sideways in the $280–$330 range. Short term traders will take profits and I wouldn't be surprised to see a pullback if the broader "AI Bubble" sentiment wavers.
  • Long Term: My thesis is unchanged. Google owns the full stack, from the chips (TPUs) to the model (Gemini) to the distribution (Android, Chrome, apps, search, etc..).

I am holding my core position, but not adding here. If you followed me into this investment in July, congrats, you are sitting on substantial gains.

Have other thoughts on Alphabet?

Create your own narrative on this stock, and estimate its Fair Value using our Valuator tool.

Create Narrative

Disclaimer

BlackGoat is an employee of Simply Wall St, but has written this narrative in their capacity as an individual investor. BlackGoat has a position in NasdaqGS:GOOG. Simply Wall St has no position in any companies mentioned. Simply Wall St may provide the securities issuer or related entities with website advertising services for a fee, on an arm's length basis. These relationships have no impact on the way we conduct our business, the content we host, or how our content is served to users. This narrative is general in nature and explores scenarios and estimates created by the author. The narrative does not reflect the opinions of Simply Wall St, and the views expressed are the opinion of the author alone, acting on their own behalf. These scenarios are not indicative of the company's future performance and are exploratory in the ideas they cover. The fair value estimate's are estimations only, and does not constitute a recommendation to buy or sell any stock, and they do not take account of your objectives, or your financial situation. Note that the author's analysis may not factor in the latest price-sensitive company announcements or qualitative material.