Loading...

If silver reaches $75/oz

Published
26 Sep 24
Updated
23 Sep 25
n/a
n/a
RockeTeller's Fair Value
n/a
Loading
1Y
486.2%
7D
-4.1%

Author's Valuation

CA$11095.4% undervalued intrinsic discount

RockeTeller's Fair Value

Last Update 23 Sep 25

Fair value Increased 10%

If silver reaches $75/oz

🪙 Discovery Silver Corp (DSV / DSVSF) – 2025 Update

Latest verified info

  • Shares Outstanding (basic): ~801 million shares. (Discovery Silver Corp.)
  • Options: ~11 million; Warrants: ~4 million; Fully Diluted Shares: ~816 million. (Discovery Silver Corp.)
  • AISC (Cordero FS): Average AISC of less than US$12.50/AgEq-oz for Years 1-8 of production in Cordero’s FS. (Discovery Silver Corp.)
  • Latest operating AISC (gold operations after Porcupine acquisition): ~US$2,123/oz for Q2 2025 in gold-selling operations. (Discovery Silver Corp.)

⚠️ Risks

  • Production cost risk: Even though Cordero’s FS shows very low AISC (~US$12.50/oz AgEq) early on, ramp-up zones, startup areas, or lower-grade areas often cost more. Real costs may exceed FS in early years or in less favourable zones.
  • Metal price risk: The model’s higher valuations assume silver/gold/base metal prices well above current levels; if prices fall, the upside drops sharply.
  • Permitting / environmental / community delays: Projects in Mexico (Cordero) still need permits, local infrastructure, environmental studies, and community agreements. Delays or objections could push timelines out.
  • Dilution / financing risk: Big projects require large upfront spending; more shares or debt may be needed, which dilutes or raises cost of capital.
  • Execution risk: Construction, metallurgy, logistics, and scaling up operations nearly always present unexpected challenges. Delivery of FS-assumed recoveries, grade, and throughput may lag or cost more.
  • Portfolio complexity: With multiple assets (Cordero + gold from Porcupine etc.), maintaining focus and avoiding cost overruns across all becomes more difficult.

⚡ Catalysts

  • Cordero Feasibility Study optimization / expansion (reducing costs, improving recoveries or scale) especially for Years 1-8 where cost is lowest.
  • Continued drill results at Cordero to expand high-grade areas or improve resource outside the pit to extend mine life.
  • Permit approvals and infrastructure development (roads, power, water) that reduce risk and capex.
  • Strong metal price environment, especially silver and gold; also favorable lead/zinc prices if those by-products contribute.
  • Financing or offtake or partnership agreements that help raise capital under good terms.
  • Operational milestones from gold operations (Porcupine) to generate cash and reduce risk of overreliance on silver project.

📊 FCF Valuation (using FS cost, fully diluted shares = ~816 million)

Method: FCF ≈ production × (price − AISC). Assumptions:

  • Use 37 million AgEq oz/year (from Cordero FS). (Discovery Silver Corp.)
  • Use AISC = US$12.50/AgEq-oz (Years 1-8 FS average cost) as placeholder for lower bound; also run higher cost scenario to show sensitivity.
  • Shares = 816 million fully diluted.

Scenario A: Silver = US$100/oz

  • Margin/oz = 100 − 12.50 = US$87.50/oz
  • Annual FCF = 37,000,000 × 87.50 = US$3,237.5M
  • Valuation multiples:   • 10× → US$32.375B → per share ≈ US$39.65/sh   • 15× → US$48.562B → ≈ US$59.47/sh   • 20× → US$64.750B → ≈ US$79.30/sh

Scenario B: Silver = US$150/oz

  • Margin/oz = 150 − 12.50 = US$137.50/oz
  • Annual FCF = 37,000,000 × 137.50 = US$5,087.5M (~US$5.0875B)
  • Valuation multiples:   • 10× → US$50.875B → per share ≈ US$62.38/sh   • 15× → US$76.313B → ≈ US$93.56/sh   • 20× → US$101.75B → ≈ US$124.75/sh

High-Cost Sensitivity Scenario: If AISC is higher (say US$30/oz) for early years or less favourable zones:

  • At US$100 silver, margin = 100 − 30 = US$70 → Annual FCF = 37M × 70 = US$2.59B → 10× ≈ US$25.9B → per share ≈ US$31.75/sh
  • At US$150 silver, margin = 150 − 30 = US$120 → Annual FCF = 37M × 120 = US$4.44B → 10× → US$44.4B → per share ≈ US$54.4/sh

📅 Expected Full Timeline (now → full production)

  • H2 2025: Continue permitting, drill infills, finalize infrastructure and FS/capacity plans. Get closer to delivering cost guidance.
  • 2026: Secure additional financing / capital; begin construction / procurement of major components; early production path mapping; engineering.
  • 2027-2028: Ramp toward full production at Cordero (Years 1-8 cost profile); show cost metrics match FS; begin cash flow.
  • 2029-2030: Extend mine life via resource expansions; refinance or optimize operations; full steady-state production under FS assumptions.

🎯 Updated Conclusion

✅ With fully diluted shares (~816M) and using very favorable FS cost (US$12.50/oz AgEq), Discovery Silver has a per-share fair value in the US$30-80/sh range under silver = US$100-150 depending on multiple.

✅ More conservative cost assumptions (e.g. US$30/oz AISC) pull that value down to US$25-55/sh range.

⚠️ Key factors to watch: actual cost performance (especially outside early years in FS), metal price environment, permitting / construction risks.

🚀 Overall, Discovery remains one of the stronger silver development plays if silver stays strong — good leverage, low cost first years, and relatively large shares base.

---

Discovery Silver: Stock Price Estimate at $75 Silver (2027)

Step 1: Revenue Estimation for 2027

Projected Production: 33M oz AgEq.

Silver Price: $75/oz.

Revenue: 33,000,000 × 75 = $2,475,000,000 USD.

---

Step 2: Free Cash Flow (FCF) Estimation

1. Costs:

AISC: $13/oz.

Total Costs: 33,000,000 × 13 = $429,000,000 USD.

2. FCF:

FCF = Revenue - Costs.

FCF = 2,475,000,000 - 429,000,000 = $2,046,000,000 USD.

---

Step 3: Market Cap Based on FCF

FCF Multiple: 10x.

Market Cap: 2,046,000,000 × 10 = $20,460,000,000 USD.

---

Step 4: Stock Price Calculation

Shares Outstanding: 200M (estimate).

Stock Price: 20,460,000,000 ÷ 200,000,000 = $102.30 USD.

---

Conclusion:

If silver reaches $75/oz by 2027 and Discovery Silver achieves 33M oz AgEq annual production, the stock price could be approximately $102.30 per share. This demonstrates the company’s strong leverage to rising silver prices and potential as a high-return investment opportunity.

How well do narratives help inform your perspective?

Disclaimer

The user RockeTeller has a position in TSX:DSV. Simply Wall St has no position in any of the companies mentioned. Simply Wall St may provide the securities issuer or related entities with website advertising services for a fee, on an arm's length basis. These relationships have no impact on the way we conduct our business, the content we host, or how our content is served to users. The author of this narrative is not affiliated with, nor authorised by Simply Wall St as a sub-authorised representative. This narrative is general in nature and explores scenarios and estimates created by the author. The narrative does not reflect the opinions of Simply Wall St, and the views expressed are the opinion of the author alone, acting on their own behalf. These scenarios are not indicative of the company's future performance and are exploratory in the ideas they cover. The fair value estimates are estimations only, and does not constitute a recommendation to buy or sell any stock, and they do not take account of your objectives, or your financial situation. Note that the author's analysis may not factor in the latest price-sensitive company announcements or qualitative material.

Read more narratives